A school kept phones in lockers. Its principal noticed a change in a simple ‘hello.’
At McPherson Middle School in Kansas, a policy requiring students to keep their cell phones in lockers throughout the school day has led to remarkable improvements in both academic and social environments. Principal Inge Esping observed a striking transformation: chronic absenteeism plummeted from 39% to 11%, and school suspensions decreased by 70%. Beyond these statistics, the most profound change was in the nature of student interactions. Esping noted a simple yet telling shift—students were more likely to reciprocate a greeting with a 'hello,' suggesting increased engagement and presence in their immediate social environment.
This change is reflective of broader trends observed in schools implementing similar policies across the country. Evidence from the nonpartisan initiative, Phones in Focus, supports these findings, with a significant rise in schools adopting phone bans and reporting enhanced student focus and social interaction. Despite some parental concerns, particularly around emergency communication, the outcomes suggest that restricting phone use can foster a richer, more connected learning environment, emphasizing face-to-face interactions over digital distractions.
Constructive analysis
The constructive-journalism lens: not just what happened, but what works.
- The problem
- The challenge of managing cell phone use in schools and its impact on student engagement and social interaction.
- The actions
- Schools, like McPherson Middle School, implemented policies requiring students to keep phones in lockers, reducing distractions and encouraging face-to-face interactions.
- Evidence of progress
- Chronic absenteeism dropped from 39% to 11%, school suspensions fell by 70%, and students began engaging more socially, responding to greetings with a 'hello.'
- What we can learn
- Other schools can learn the importance of setting clear boundaries around phone use to enhance student focus and social skills, despite potential parental concerns.
PERMA profile of this story
How this story scores across the PERMA dimensions.
- Positive Emotion
- 8
- Engagement
- 9
- Relationships
- 7
- Meaning
- 8
- Accomplishment
- 8
Character strengths in play
Top VIA strengths this story embodies.
Hope
The results after three years were 'pretty wild.' Chronic absenteeism dropped from 39% to 11%, and school suspensions fell by 70%.
Courage
For Esping, parents were split 50/50. 'We had about half of our parents who were incredibly excited for this change, and about half of our parents that were very nervous.'
Curiosity
Teachers are seeing students talk in hallways face-to-face and engage in the kind of social learning that can't happen through a screen.
Try this today
Try a 'phone-free hour' each day where you engage in face-to-face conversations or activities without the distraction of your phone. Observe any changes in how you connect with others during this time.